📖 ReadingGrade 2Lesson 15
← Back🔒 PDF with full access

Compare Two Short Stories

Lesson preview: the Mini Lesson and Vocabulary are open to everyone. Guided practice, exercises, the parent checklist and the printable PDF worksheet come with full access (free 7-day trial or membership).

Learning Objectives

  • 1Read two short stories
  • 2Compare them using story elements
  • 3Identify similarities (character, setting, problem, lesson) using a Venn diagram
  • 4Write comparison sentences using "Both stories…" and "Story 1 … but Story 2 …" frames
📘

Mini Lesson

When you compare two stories, you look for what they share and what makes each one unique. Comparing helps you think more deeply about both stories and understand them better.

What to compare — four story elements

  • Characters — Who is in each story? Are they similar or different people?
  • Setting — Where and when does each story happen?
  • Problem — What challenge do the characters face? Is it the same type of problem?
  • Lesson — What does each story teach? Do they share the same message?

The Venn diagram tool

  • Draw two overlapping circles — one for each story.
  • Things that are only in Story 1 go in the left circle.
  • Things that are only in Story 2 go in the right circle.
  • Things that are the same in both go in the middle overlap.

Comparison sentence frames

  • "Both stories…" — for similarities.
  • "Story 1 … but Story 2 …" — for differences.
  • "The settings are different because…"
  • "Both characters face the problem of…"
Venn Diagram for Comparing Two StoriesA Venn diagram with two overlapping circles. The left circle is labeled Story 1 Only with examples character and setting. The middle overlap is labeled Both with examples same problem and same lesson. The right circle is labeled Story 2 Only with examples different character and different setting.Venn Diagram — Comparing StoriesStory 1OnlyStory 2OnlyBothcharactersettingdetailssameproblemsamelessoncharactersettingdetailsMiddle = same in BOTH stories
A Venn diagram — left circle for Story 1 only, right for Story 2 only, middle for what they share.
Comparison Sentence FramesFour comparison sentence frames shown in colored boxes: Both stories have the same lesson, Story 1 is set in a forest but Story 2 is set in a city, Both characters face the problem of being lost, and The settings are different because one is indoors and one is outdoors.Comparison Sentence Frames"Both stories…"Both stories have the same lesson about hard work."Story 1 … but Story 2 …"Story 1 is in a forest but Story 2 is in a city."Both characters face the problem of…"Both characters face the problem of being lost."The settings are different because…"…one is indoors and one is outdoors.
Four comparison sentence frames for writing about similarities and differences.
💡

Ask yourself: "What do these two stories share? What is unique to each one? Could I swap the characters or settings and tell the same story?"

Vocabulary
Compare
To look at two things and find how they are the same and how they are differente.g. Comparing two stories by looking at their characters, settings, problems, and lessons.
Similarity
Something that is the same in both storiese.g. Both stories have a character who makes a foolish choice.
Difference
Something that is NOT the same in the two storiese.g. Story 1 is set near a tree, but Story 2 is set in a field and a nest.
Venn diagram
Two overlapping circles used to show similarities (middle) and differences (outer parts)e.g. The middle overlap shows what both stories share.
Free · 7 days · No credit card

Unlock the full HSEA system for 7 days.

Add your first kid profile and your 7 days start: every lesson in every grade, saved progress for each child. Nothing to set up, no card required, nothing to cancel.

  • ✓ All 1,680 lessons, Grades 1–6, every subject
  • ✓ Profiles + saved progress for every kid
  • ✓ Printable lessons with answer key
Start your 7-day free trial →
Already convinced? See full membership plans →
← Lesson 14: Find Moral or Life LessonLesson 16: Write a Mini Book Review →